GOVERNMENT BAN ON NEHRU-GANDHIS BOOK IN HINDI PATENTLY ILLEGAL AND BLATANTLY DISCRIMINATORY
V. SUNDARAM I.A.S
V. SUNDARAM I.A.S
The Government of India in the Ministry of Home Affairs has recently banned a book in Hindi titled Nehru Gandhi Parivar: Secular ya Varnasankar (Nehru-Gandhi Family: Secular or Half-Castes) authored by Shri Hariram Gupta, a resident of Bhopal on the nebulous and flimsy ground that the allegations made against the Italian Catholic (Nehru-Gandhi) HALF-BREED Family in the book are malicious and insidious, and unsupported by documented facts. The book, which has chapters on Sonia Gandhi and on the ‘business dealings’ of Rahul Gandhi, is a Hindi translation of a collection of articles in English posted on the Internet. THOUGH THE BOOK HAS BEEN BANNED, THESE WEB POSTS CAN STILL BE ACCESSED ON THE INTERNET.
Hariram Gupta, a resident of Bhopal who has authored the book, has said his intention is to “expose the so-called secularists and enlighten the public so that Indian Hindu society is freed from the fell clutches of Nehru - Indira Gandhi – Sonia Gandhi Family”.
The Government of India has also alleged that the statements against Jawaharlal Nehru and Indira Gandhi in the book are defamatory and scandalous. How can the Union Ministry of Home Affairs bring up the charge of defamation against Shri Hariram Gupta and issue a notice on behalf of the deceased leaders like Nehru and Indira Gandhi?
It is established law that defamation cases can be filed only by those individuals who have been individually named, wronged and defamed. If Sonia Gandhi or Rahul Gandhi or Priyanka Gandhi strongly feels that he or she has been defamed by Shri Hariram Gupta, then that person should file defamation petition individually and separately against the author. The Union Ministry of Home Affairs has no locus standi whatsoever in this matter. They have no business to treat the Union Home Ministry as their exclusive private firm of Lawyers and Attorneys to handle their imaginary defamation cases! In actual practice firangi memsahib Sonia Gandhi and the leading members of her HALF-BREED FAMILY are blatantly using (no doubt abusing!) the Sonia-slavish and shamelessly Sonia-servile official machinery of the Government of India as their inherited private estate to put down Freedom of Speech and Freedom of Thought and Expression guaranteed as a Fundamental Right under the Indian Constitution. This disgraceful and wholly dishonourable effect is achieved through the wholly enthusiastic and ever willing compliance and supplication of our invertebrate Prime Minister who is a standing monument of our national shame and folly!
Javier Moro Cover page of Moro’s Book
(El sari rojo/ The red sari
(Seix Barral Biblioteca Breve)
(Spanish Edition) (Paperback))
This Spanish book The Red Sari is subtitled When Life is the Price of Power. It is a reference to the red sari Sonia wore on her wedding day, "one that Nehru wove while he was in jail". This was first published in October 2008, and it has already been translated into Italian, French and Dutch, and an English translation by Peter Hearn is ready for publication. It has been reported that already more than 2,30,000 copies have already been sold in Spain, Italy and Latin America.
In an email, freely available on the internet Javier Moro, the author of this book The Red Sari, has said that Sonia's lawyers, including Congress spokesperson Abhishek Singhvi, "have just written to my Italian and Spanish publishers to demand the withdrawal of the book from the stores. Nobody understands very well why, but that's what they are up to". Moro is of the view that the Congress leaders "did not like the recreation of her life in Italy as told in my book".
SHINING SYMBOL OF SONIA CONGRESS TALIBAN CULTURE
The Sonia Congress Party is demanding the imposition of a ban on this book The Red Sari. It has been reported that Moro has said: "Sonia's legal counsel even objected to a part in the book wherein I have said that Sonia wonders, after Rajiv's assassination, as to whether she should return to Italy on her mother's advice. I think they would like to believe that Sonia had been thoroughly Indianised by then and would not even consider going back to Italy." Moro also seems to have added with sardonic humour: "THEY WOULD MUCH PREFER THAT SHE HAD BEEN BORN IN DELHI -- AND FROM A BRAHMIN FAMILY, IF POSSIBLE."
One thing is very clear. The Union Ministry of Home Affairs which is part of the private inherited political Estate of the firangi memsahib Sonia and her HALF-BREED FAMILY is ever in a state of combat-readiness to ban all books and publications giving factual details about the globally known shady and murky background of the firangi memsahib Sonia. All the basic truths about this firangi memsahib have been fully documented and exposed by Dr.Subramanian Swami on his website.
The anti-Hindu Italian Colonial Government of India is only worried about no one hurting the feelings, emotions and sentiments of this Roman Catholic firangi memsahib Sonia and her family. THIS IRRESPONSIBLE GOVERNMENT FUNCTIONING UNDER THE EVER FLOUNDERING CONTROL OF THE EUNUCH BONELESS-WONDER OF A SURROGATE PRIME MINISTER SEEMS TO HAVE NOTHING BUT CONTEMPT BORDERING ON HATRED FOR THE RELIGIOUS FEELINGS, EMOTIONS AND SENTIMENTS OF THE HINDUS OF INDIA. Let me illustrate this point.
For example, if a book were to be written defaming the highly respected RSS leader, like Guruji Golwalkar, then THE UNION MINISTRY OF HOME AFFAIRS WOULD TAKE NO ACTION WHATSOEVER AGAINST THE AUTHOR OF THAT BOOK. In fact the author of such a book would be recommended for a Padmasri Award to be conferred by the President of India! Three or four years ago the wretched firangi memsahib had the temerity to suggest that the RSS should be banned because it is a “Right-Wing” organization of the Hindus. During the Golwalkar Centenary Year, this traitorous firangi memsahib had made disparaging comments against the revered Golwalkarji, thereby hurting the feelings of millions of his Hindu admirers.
Another firangi memsahib is Wendy Doniger, Professor of the History of Religions at the University of Chicago, who has authored a book called ‘The Hindus: An Alternative History’. Cast in the same condemnable anti-Hindu evangelical mould, Wendy Doniger is a sex-obsessed pornographer masquerading as a historian or linguist or call it what you will. As a former belly dancer, she sees eroticism and sex in everything with a titillating excitement to boot and her comments on Hindu sacred texts are replete with cheap and vulgar sexual innuendos.
All her special works have revolved around the subject of sex in Sanskrit texts ranging from ‘Siva: The Erotic Ascetic’ to ‘Tales of Sex and Violence’. Never one to shy away from sex, she threw herself into the job of translating the Kama Sutra. She was particularly interested by the parts that justify adultery, indicating the ways to a woman as to how she should get rid of an unwanted lover. When she was translating it, she frequently found herself having to take cold showers.” [ref: Interview with Wendy Doniger, March 27, 2002, BBC Radio]
According to Dr. Nicholas Kazanas, a Greek Indologist and Sanskritist, “Wendy Doniger seems to see only one function, that of sexuality, defloration, copulation, fertility, castration and the like. Even bhakti or devotion is described in stark erotic terms including incest and homosexuality”. Wendy Doniger is always obsessed with the most sexual spin imaginable based on the greatest amount of stretching of the erotic imagery, overruling all other interpretations and varied aspects of meaning. Let me now have recourse to Wendy Doniger’s sex-mad lingua franca. This sex-deprived, sex-obsessed, barbarous woman is a fit candidate for compulsory sex therapy.
In my view, she brings in her personal sexual frustration into her pornographic book on Hinduism. I am saying this because she seems to have been greatly influenced by the sexual theories of Sigmund Freud (1856-1939) and her comments on Hindu Gods and Goddesses are nothing but pornography cloaked in pseudo-Freudean babble and blah-blah.
Hindu Janajagruti Samiti activists protested in New York on 11 March 2010 describing Wendy Doniger's book, as containing “factual errors, mischaracterizations and hatred for Hindus." Her book, they say, “is a work that promotes bigotry, racism and intolerance. No civilized or decent human being, organization or society will ever support such a book, given the persistent verbal violence noticed in this book against the Hindus.”
Wendy Doniger once delivered a lecture on the Mahabharata in Chicago on the subject "The Complicity of God in the Destruction of the Human Race". Throughout this lecture, she consistently took the view that “in the Mahabharata story Krishna goads human beings into all sorts of murderous and self-destructive behaviours”. For her the Bhagavad Gita is a “dishonest book; it justifies war”! Ofcourse, if Sri Krishna had said something then it must be bad, paganish and heathenish from Wendy Doniger’s evangelical hate-filled point of view. This evangelical fool does not realize that Arjuna was about to desert his army in the battlefield in the epic Mahabharata war. An act of desertion in a battle field would have merited a swift military execution and Sri Krishna was trying to prevent Arjuna, an awe inspiring warrior from being a cowardly army deserter and rekindle in him the sense of his ordained martial duties.
The Credo of the Indian Military Academy taken from a passage from the inaugural address by Field Marshal Sir Philip Chetwode (1869-1950), Baronet GCB, OM, GCSI, KCMG, DSO, then Commander-in-Chief of India reads as follows:
come first, always and every time.
The Honour, Welfare and Comfort of the Men
you command come next.
Your Own ease, Comfort and Safety
come last, always and everytime"
This is the motto of the officers passing out from the Indian Military Academy.
Sri Krishna’s words to Arjuna were also to the same effect. But the evangelist Wendy Doniger claims that the Bhagavad Gita is a “dishonest book; it justifies war”!
This is the motto of the officers passing out from the Indian Military Academy.
Sri Krishna’s words to Arjuna were also to the same effect. But the evangelist Wendy Doniger claims that the Bhagavad Gita is a “dishonest book; it justifies war”!
“Onward, Christian Soldiers” is a 19th century English hymn. The words were written by Sabine Baring-Gould in 1865, and the music was composed by Arthur Sullivan in 1871. Sullivan named the tune "St. Gertrude," after the wife of his friend Ernest Clay Ker Seymer, at whose country home he composed the tune. The Salvation Army adopted the hymn as its favoured processional. The hymn's theme is taken from references in the New Testament to the Christian being a soldier for Christ, for example II Timothy 2:3 (KJV): "Thou shalt endure hardness, as a good soldier of Jesus Christ."
Don’t believe for a moment that the word “soldier” is not to be taken literally. The Christian priest and evangelist had always followed on the heels of the Christian soldiers carrying the banner of the Cross.
When British Prime Minister Sir Winston Churchill and the American President Franklin Roosevelt met in 1941 on the battleship HMS Prince of Wales to draw up the Atlantic Charter, a church service was held for which Prime Minister Churchill chose the hymns. He chose "Onward, Christian Soldiers" and afterwards made a radio broadcast explaining this choice:
“We sang ‘Onward, Christian Soldiers’ indeed, and I felt that this was no vain presumption, but that we had the right to feel that we serving a cause for the sake of which a trumpet has sounded from on high. When I looked upon that densely packed congregation of fighting men of the same language, of the same faith, of the same fundamental laws, of the same ideals ... it swept across me that here was the only hope, but also the sure hope, of saving the world from measureless degradation.”
Whether Wendy Doniger likes it or not, wants it or not, approves it or not, the devout Hindus of India feel the same way as Winston Churchill about Lord Krishna’s message to Arjuna in the Bhagavat Geeta. When the Christian Franklin Roosevelt calls for war, it is patriotic, When the Christian Winston Churchill calls for war, it is patriotic, but when the Hindu God Sri Krishna calls for war then it is disgusting for the pornographer-cum-evangelist Wendy Doniger! Let her continue to stew in the stinking juice of her anti-Hindu evangelism!
What is disgusting for a snake that steals bird eggs? The sight of birds putting up an organized defence! What is disgusting for a laughing hyena preying on gazelle fawn? The sight of gazelle herd putting up a solid defence. What is disgusting for pornographer-cum-evangelist Wendy Doniger? The very thought of Sri Krishna’s exhortation to Arjuna to take up weapons and fight for Righteousness and thereby inspiring millions of Hindu youth to organize themselves in the defence of Sanatana Dharma. This is enough to shake the foundations of her monotheistic evangelism!
Here is another of Wendy Doniger’s hate filled Hindu denigrating, motivated evangelical tome. This I found on the University of Chicago website: “there is no evidence that Rama was born in the place that is now known as Ayodha and there is no evidence that there was a Hindu temple on the spot where the Babur Mosque was. And that there is no evidence that Rama and a bunch of monkeys built a bridge from India to Sri Lanka, as the Hindu Right have claimed. That’s just mythology, which is lovely, I’ve studied it all my life, but you don’t legislate on the basis of mythology.” First of all, Ramayana is not “mythology” but a Testament of Faith for the billion strong Hindu people. And yes, legislation can be made on the basis of faith, after all the American Evangelicals like Wendy Doniger and her equally evangelical Government of United States, are supporting Saudi Arabia, whose Constitution is the Kuran itself. Now, about her claim about Sri Ram never being born in Ayodhya I have to quote Dr Satya Pal Singh from his article titled ‘Proving the Historicity of Ram’:
“The most authentic and original source of knowledge about Ram is the Valmiki Ramayana. This noble work of literature credits Valmiki as the earliest poet of the world. The story of Ram did not remain confined to the pages of Valmiki Ramayana, but it also finds a mention in various other scriptures of history and ancient literature. It is talked about in Muni Vyas's Mahabharata; in Buddhist literature it finds mention in three Jataka parables, viz, Dashrath Jataka, Anamak Jataka and Dashrath Kathanak; in Jain literature many manuscripts were written on Ram, like Padam Charitra (Prakrit) by Vimal Suri; Padam Puran (Sanskrit) by Ravisen Acharya; Padam Charitra (Apbhransh) and Charitra Puran (Sanskrit) by Swambhu; and Uttar Puran (Sanskrit) by Gunbhadra. The story of Ram was also written in various other Indian regional languages. More than 400 great poets and saints like Kalidas, Bhas, Bhatti, Praversen, Bhavbhuti, Kshemendra, Rajshekhar, Kumardas, Vishwanath, Somdev, Gunadutt, Narad, Lomesh, Guru Govind Singh, the Samarth Guru Ramdas, Maithili Sharan Gupt, Keshavdas and Saint Tukdoji etc, have written poems, prose and literature on Ram and other characters of the Ramayana. Even in other countries we can find versions of Ramayana, like the Tibetan Ramayana, Turkistan's Khotani Ramayana, Indonesia's Kakbin Ramayana, Java's Seratram, Sairiram, Ramkeling, Patani Ramkatha; Indo-China's Ramkerti (Ramkirti), Khamer Ramayana; Burma's Ramyagan of Yuto; Thailand's Ramkiyen etc all narrate the story of Ram in a picturesque way. Scholars also believe that Homer's Illiad and the Dionysia of poet Nonus of Rome have surprising similarities with our Ramayana. In world literature, no other historical person has been narrated with so much devotion on such a grand, magnified and detailed scale by so many poets and authors of varied countries.” THE KING OF THAILAND TAKES THE TITLE “RAMA” and not JESUS CHRIST, THE SAVIOUR ON HIS CORONATION!!
Several outstanding historians including Edward Gibbon (a world famous and genuine Anglican Christian indeed!) have clearly pointed out that there is no reference to Jesus Christ in the vast historical and philosophical literature left behind by the Greeks and the Romans belonging to the generally accepted time-bracket when Jesus is supposed to have lived. For example, Seneca (2 BC-66 AD), Pliny, the Elder (23 AD-79 AD), Martial (40 AD-102 AD), Plutarch (45 AD-125 AD), Juvenal (55 AD-140 AD) and many others do not mention any Jesus or Christ in their well known works and writings. There is no irrefutable historical or scientific proof that Jesus Christ ever existed. Will firangi memsahib Wendy Doniger ever dare to dismiss the Bible as unscientific and mythological text? Since Wendy Doniger is a Jew will she dismiss the Old Testament as well as unscientific and mythological as the New Testament?
I know that Wendy Doniger would be quite incensed by the observations of Edward Gibbon on the fraudulent origins of the myth of Jesus Christ. If Wendy Doniger can have the savagely wild imagination to compare Guruji Golwalkar with Aurangazeb and Brigadier General Dyer, then I have no doubt that she would even go to the extent of denigrating Edward Gibbon as being closely related to one of the forefathers of Guruji Golwalkar in the 18th Century! So much for the paranoid evangelical pornographic paroxysms of Wendy Doniger from Chicago. Even the best neuropsychiatrists of America may not be able to deal with the perverted aberrations of Wendy Doniger in her book on Hinduism.
Dr. S. Badrinarayanan, Geologist and former Director of Geological survey of India and Consultant for National institute of Ocean Technology, has said “Geological & geophysical studies of Ram Setu reveal the presence of loose marine deposits below the coral layer clearly indicating the coral layer in the form of boulders are not natural and formed on their own, but have been transported by somebody and dumped there; thus clearly establishing the fact that Ram Sethu is very much man-made in the hoary past”. But our lust-crazed belly dancer from Chicago turned sex-obsessed, sex-deprived, ageing evangelist Wendy Doniger closes her eyes and exclaims, “there is no evidence for Ram Sethu”!!!
Dr. S. Kalyanaraman, Founder of the Sarasvati Research and Education Trust posted an online Petition requesting Penguin Books to withhold publication of edition of Wendy Doniger’s book, as it is “rife with numerous errors in its historical facts and Sanskrit translations”, “intended to mislead students of Indian and Hindu history” and “analyzes revered Hindu Gods and Goddess using her widely discredited psychosexual Freudian theories that modern, humanistic psychology has deemed limiting”.
The whole wide spectrum of criticism of the Wendy Doniger’s latest pornographic work has come mostly from moderate and liberal Hindus, secularists and non-Hindu scholars. Further even one prominent Harvard Indologist Michael Witzel who is known for virulently anti-Hindu stances has mentioned, among other things, that he counted 43 instances of wrong translation done by Wendy Doniger in respect of one hymn containing 18 stanzas. Renowned Scholars of Sanskrit, from the West and India, have rejected Dr. Doniger’s fraudulent claims of being a scholar in Sanskrit. This is our “acclaimed Sanskrit scholar and author”, firangi memsahib Wendy Doniger from the United States of America.
Firangi memsahib Wendy Doniger loves to expand on women’s "reproductive rights”. It is a well-known fact historically women in every ancient culture were treated subordinate to men, especially in Jewish, Christian and Islamic societies. Did not God of Abraham condemn women to “bear children in sorrow”? St. Paul told women to keep their mouths shut in church congregations and advising them to ask their husbands if they had any questions! In England the practice of “rule of thumb” prevailed, condoning beating of wives with a stick no thicker than her husband’s thumb! Dr. Seshachalam Dutta, in an article titled ‘Why “The Hindus: An Alternative History” Is Not Banned in India?’ published on June 11, 2010 says: “Throughout her voluminous book Doniger feigns sympathy for Hindu women and other oppressed castes. If she needs comparative analysis of womanhood of various religious groups, Hindus at least are not guilty of female circumcision (genital mutilation) as currently practiced in some Muslim and Jewish communities.” IT NEEDS TO BE MENTIONED HERE THAT BOTH THE PARENTS OF WENDY DONIGER WERE JEWISH.
Firangi memsahib Wendy Doniger is backed by evangelical American publishers and a private Christian Institution, Divinity School of the University of Chicago. As a result many American institutions and individuals have endorsed her books without scrutinizing her qualifications and in complete disregard to the Sentiments of a billion strong Hindu people. She has given more students (Wendy’s illegitimate offsprings) their Ph.Ds in Hinduism than any other person in the world and has successfully placed these former students in high-leverage academic jobs throughout the Western world, to carry the torch of her perverted theories and prostituted principles for researching on the vending of WENDIAN HINDUISM with the intention of demeaning and denigrating Hinduism.
Firangi memsahib from America, Wendy Doniger brackets M.S Golwalkar with Aurangazeb and Brigadier General Dyer. Guruji Golwalkar was an organized, disciplined, dedicated, non-violent patriotic social reformer all his life. Wendy Doniger has no business to equate Guruji Golwalkar with Aurangazeb and Brigadier General Dyer. Aurangazeb slaughtered thousands of Hindus and destroyed Hundreds of Temples with Islamic fervour and hatred. Brigadier General Dyer was personally responsible for the massacre and carnage at Jallianwala Bagh on 13 April 1919. She and her publisher can be sued for defaming RSS as participants or conspirators in Gandhi’s assassination and sexual innuendoes in matters religious may be treated as blasphemous. Wendy Doniger seems to share the same hatred and contempt for the respected Hindu leader Guruji Golwalkar as the Italian Catholic imposter firangi memsahib Sonia in New Delhi.
In my view, Wendy Doniger’s book on Hinduism is the most demeaning, denigrating, degrading, damning and scurrilous book which eminently qualifies to be totally banned by the Government of India. I hope the Government of India will show at least as much sensitivity as the American corporation Microsoft has done or else it will prove that it is in reality an evangelical Italian colonial dispensation, in which case it becomes the bounden duty of every patriotic Indian citizen to overthrow this alien regime.
Any book similar to this one on Muslims would have invited worldwide wrath among the Muslims leading to fatwa’s and no publisher would have dared to publish such a work. That is why I say that the Hindus must become more organized and more militant and more willing to take to the streets and vociferously raise Hindu issues and force the evangelical cum Islamic anti-Hindu UPA II Government to take immediate notice of the rising crescendo of injured feelings, emotions and passions of the Hindus of India.
This demeaning pornography book by Wendy Doniger brings to my mind Katherine Mayo’s equally scurrilous book titled ‘The Face of Mother India’ which was published in 1927. That book too was written in a sensationalized and muckraking style against the Hindus, Hindu Gods and Goddesses. The book was burned in India (along with her effigy) and New York City. Mahatma Gandhi denounced the book as untruthful and said: “It resembles a drain inspectors report”. It wasn’t just native Indians who found her books distasteful, as there were many protesters in America and England. Taking note of wounded Hindu public feelings, emotions and sentiments, the Government of India banned Katherine Mayo’s‘ The Face of Mother India’ in 18 January 1936.
Against this background it should be clear that it is the bounden public duty of the Government of India to ban Wendy Doniger’s book ‘The Hindus: An Alternative History’ immediately. Firangi memsahib will take lightning action to get only a factual book on the NEHRU-GANDHI HALF-BREED FAMILY BANNED and not a scurrilous book on Hinduism authored by a missionary-backed firangi memsahib (another Sonia Gandhi!) from America. If any civilized Government (the Sonia Congress UPA II Government is definitely not!) has a justification to ban a book, this is the one. Indian Government is not to be credited with the virtue of the freedom of press or tolerance to intellectual works when it comes to attack on religious sensibilities of the Hindus. More innocuous work, Satanic Verses, by Salman Rushdie was banned by the Government of India before it hit the book stores because the Government of India felt that the feelings of the terrorist Muslims (compassionate Islam!) of India were involved!
I AM GIVING THIS EXAMPLE ONLY TO HIGHLIGHT THE FACT THAT THE UNION HOME MINISTRY BELIEVES IN THE PHILOSOPHY AND POLICY OF BLATANT AND OPEN DISCRIMINATION WHICH ONLY RESULTS IN replacing the Rule of Law by the Italian Colonial Rule of the firangi memsahib Sonia.
Another controversial book which is now in the news is titled ‘Shivaji: Hindu King in Islamic India’ authored by James W. Laine.
I would like to ask this question. Was India ever Islamic at any time in her history? There were waves and waves of Islamic plundering expeditions and outright invasions since the 12th century AD. Certain parts of India had Muslim rulers who imposed the draconian Sharia law and humiliated the Hindus with Jaziya payments and yet India retained its majority Hindu demography which continued to follow its own religious tenets. So the very title -- ‘Hindu King in Islamic India’ is astonishing. It indicates that the author has very little familiarity with the subject on which he is pontificating, viewing it as a ‘White Man’s Burden’ as in the days of the British Raj!
CHHATRAPATI SHIVAJI MAHARAJ
To all the patriotic Indians of India in general and to all the Maharashtrains in particular, Shivaji was a nation-builder, a constructive visionary genius and a brilliant military general, who succeeded in giving a death-blow to the Mughal Empire under the fanatical and cruel jihadi Badshah Aurangazeb. Historians like Jadunath Sarkar have rightly declared that it was Shivaji inspired his countrymen with a fiery militant spirit of patriotism and made them unite against the Islamic tyranny of Aurangazeb. Islamic and English historians and later day Communist historians of post-Independent India have tried to run down Shivaji as a “mountain rat”, “a guerrilla of the hills” and “a narrow-minded fanatic Hindu rebel” who was only a mountain brigand whose nefarious activities led to total anarchy and disintegration of the country, finally paving the way for the establishment of British colonial rule.
James W. Laine questions the general view that Shivaji's Maratha Hindu nationalism was at war with Islamic Mughal Imperialism in the 17th century India. According to Laine, Shivaji had employed pan-Indian symbols, definitely not the regional ones. According to him, the communal and religious identities in the last quarter of the 17th Century were quite fluid and had not crystallised into water tight compartments as is often made out. He further makes the fantastic claim that sufis and Hindu saints walked a common ground during Shivaji’s time, and there was not much religious gulf between the Hindu kaffirs and the Muslims believers, despite the spate of Quranic injunctions to the contrary. In the light of this footloose analysis, James Laine concludes that to regard Shivaji as an Indian patriot is absolutely wrong and that myths woven round him give a distorted picture of the reality.
The 17th century Maratha ballad writers based the heroic legend of Shivaji as a heroic Chhatrapati of an independent Hindu kingdom on his escape from the Agra fort, his killing of Afzal Khan, his encounter with Shaista Khan, his conquest of Simhagarh, his coronation in 1674 and his dedication to his patron Goddess, Bhavani. Laine argues that the ballad writers had deliberately skipped Shivaji's military service under Adil Shah, his defeat against the Mughals, his loss of Poona, his surrender to Aurangzeb, his readiness to become a Mughal vassal with the aspiration of being designated Viceroy of the Deccan and enlisting his son in the Mughal army. James Laine has concluded that these omissions give a false image of Shivaji. Further he has come to the totally baseless and wrong conclusion that Samarth Ramdas was never Shivaji’s guru and spiritual guide. Laine himself admits in the book, he has cavalierly presented gossip and innuendo without an iota of documentary substantiation, and then on that basis, proceeded to construct his flawed argument.
No one can ignore the fact that most of the Ballads composed between 1869 and 2001 present the image of Shivaji as an epic hero. Except Grant Duff, who in his History of the Mahratta, described Shivaji a plunderer and a freebooter, all the other Indian historians and writers, including Justice M.G. Ranade and B.G. Tikak, have extolled him as the Father of Indian Nationalism and a CREATOR OF THE MAHARATTA HINDU NATION. Justice Ranade has portrayed Shivaji as the Chief Architect of Maratha Independence who promoted egalitarian status of women. In justification of some of Shivaji's actions, Tilak cites Arjuna's example from The Mahabharata. Tilak comments that great men are exempted from following the strict standard of conventional morality. Indian leaders such as Lala Lajpat Rai, B. G. Tilak, Annie Besant, Aurobindo Ghosh and poet Tagore have paid eloquent tributes to Shivaji as a great national leader and the builder of the country. James Laine has dismissed such views in a flippant manner.
Some years ago, Laine’s book on Shivaji was banned by the Government of Maharashtra on the ground that it was “promoting social enmity”. When the matter was taken on appeal to the Bombay High Court, the Bombay High Court issued Orders stating that the ban was not sustainable as the Supreme Court had already quashed criminal proceedings against Laine for allegedly “promoting social enmity”. The Bombay High Court issued this Order in 2007. The State Government of Maharashtra then moved the Supreme Court of India, which recently has upheld the Bombay High Court’s order removing the ban on the book in question.
This verdict left the Government of Maharashtra State rather embarrassed and uncertain about how to tackle the political maelstrom that the verdict of the Supreme Court of India had unleashed.
Shri Balasaheb Mohite-Patil, President of the all India Maratha Mahasangh, Marathwada Region had warned that if anyone tries to rub salt on the wounds of the Marathas by selling the book by James Laine, such person will not be spared. He said further that Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj is the pride of Hindus. The verdict has gone against us because the State Govt. has failed to properly present its case in the Court. But the book should not be sold in the market. This is a matter related to social and religious issue. Insult meted out to Rajmata Jijau and Chhatrapati Shivaji by presenting untrue incidents is an insult to the true history and will not be tolerated by ‘All India Chhava Sanghatana, Maratha Mahasangh and Warkari Mahamandal’. With outfits such as the Sambhaji Brigade taking to the streets, maintaining law and order has become a major headache for the State administration. The Shiv Sena and other political parties are in no mood to meekly submit to the Orders of the ‘Islamized’ Supreme Court of India.
Shri Subhash Javale-Patil, a senior leader of ‘All India Chhava Sanghatana’ declared that people of Maharashtra will not tolerate such mockery of Hindu history. He has said “Such mockery of history can have adverse effects on the people. Wrong information and message reaching people has to be stopped. Hindus are very discontented due to such slanderous matter written about their national leader History should depict the true picture. So far, the Government has been very firm on the issue. The Court should re-examine the facts and bring a ban on the said book”.
With the Hindu organizations promptly registering their protests against the attacks on national heroes and threatening action, the lassitude of the Government of Maharashtra regarding Sanatana Dharma and religious sentiments of the Hindus of Maharashtra quickly vanished.
Fearing mass Hindu upsurge the publishers have backtracked with the Government of Maharashtra announcing that the Oxford University Press (India), has given an assurance to the State Government that it will not print or circulate copies of the book. Maharashtra Home Minister RR Patil said Laine has given an affidavit that the controversial remarks be deleted from the book.
A demand was made by Shri. Nitin Gadkari, a leader of BJP in the Legislative Council to prohibit James Laine from visiting Maharashtra as the people of Maharashtra were incensed with James Laine, author of the book that has controversial and offensive matter about Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj. His demand was quickly agreed to by the Chief Minister who promised that he would write to the External Affairs Ministry in the matter.
Let me now move on to another book similar to the book on Shivaji authored by James Laine but written by a terrorist Muslim writer called Muhammad Kalim Siddiqui. UNDER THREAT OF VIOLENCE BY SHIV SENA THE ITALIAN COLONIAL GOVERNMENT OF INDIA BANNED THIS BOOK titled 'Apki Amanat' Nashik (Maharashtra)IN 2007.
The Malegaon police woke up from their slumber with a rude shock after the Shiv Sena threatened to burn all the books named defaming Hindu deities authored by a Muslim maulana Muhammad Kalim Siddiqui, which were distributed to the public. The Sena also lodged a complaint against the publisher of the book Armugan Publications from Uttar Pradesh.
The maulanas from Uttar Pradesh had hatched a conspiracy to create communal tension and riots between Hindus and Muslims and luring poor Hindus to embrace Islam. As the Shiv Sena's appeal to the police fell on deaf ears this Muslim group enhanced its activities with greater zest. This resulted in further agitation amongst the Hindus. The Shiv Sena then warned and threatened that if no action was taken against the erring parties then they would not hesitate to agitate and take the matter to the streets. The police finally filed cases against the author and publisher of the book for trying to create communal tension and attempting to disrupt law and order. I am giving this example to illustrate that the barbarous and Anti-Hindu firangi memsahib’s UPA II Government of India will show greater deference to the feelings of the Hindus of India only if they too follow the compassionate ways of their Muslim brethren (so beloved of firangi memsahib and her corrupt and servile Congress mercenaries!)
I
Section 153A of the Indian Penal Code says, inter alia:
“Whoever (a) by words, either spoken or written, or by signs or by visible representations or otherwise, promotes or attempts to promote, on grounds of religion, race, place of birth, residence, language, caste or community or any other ground whatsoever, disharmony or feelings of enmity, hatred or ill-will between different religious, racial, language or regional groups or castes or communities, or (b) commits any act which is prejudicial to the maintenance of harmony between different religious, racial, language or regional groups or castes or communities, and which disturbs or is likely to disturb the public tranquility, . . . shall be punished with imprisonment which may extend to three years, or with fine, or with both.”
II
Enacted in 1927, Section 295A of the Indian Penal Code says:
“Whoever, with deliberate and malicious intention of outraging the religious feelings of any class of [citizens of India], [by words, either spoken or written, or by signs or by visible representations or otherwise], insults or attempts to insult the religion or the religious beliefs of that class, shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to [three years], or with fine, or with both”.
III
Section 95 of the Code of Criminal Procedure gives the government the right to declare certain publications “forfeited” if the “publication ... appears to the State Government to contain any matter the publication of which is punishable under Section 124A or Section 153A or Section 153B or Section 292 or Section 293 or Section 295A of the Indian Penal Code”.
The Congress Governments after Independence from the days of Nehru after August 15, 1947 to the days of Narasimha Rao in 1996 have been pro-Christian, pro-Islamic and anti-Hindu. Consequently, during this period of 49 years, every Muslim terrorist and criminal or every evangelical terrorist or criminal, could take the political and official support of the Government of India for granted in all their nefarious anti-Hindu activities. They were given the advantage of special “Minority Rights” under Articles 25 to 30 of the Indian Constitution. This meant that only the Muslims and the Christians could enjoy the legal rights under Section 153A or Section 153B or Section 292 or Section 293 or Section 295A of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) or Section 95 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC). HINDUS HAVE BEEN DENIED THEIR LEGITIMATE LEGAL RIGHTS UNDER ALL THESE ABOVE SECTIONS. That is why every dastardly Muslim marauder like that pornographic Islamic painter M.F Hussein felt that he had unlimited Islamic Minority freedom to paint HINDU GODS AND GODDESSES IN THE NUDE IN THE MOST VULGAR AND INDECENT MANNER. THE FIRANGI MEMSAHIB CATHOLIC IMPOSTER DIRECTED ANTI-HINDU GOVERNMENT OF INDIA NEVER TOOK ANY ACTION TO BAN THE PAINTINGS OF M.F HUSSEIN UNDER SECTION 95 OF CrPC. Goddess Durga can be painted in the most vulgar manner by M.F Hussein but no author can give even factual truths about the atrocious deeds or misdeeds of firangi memsahib and many of the members of her HALF-BREED FAMILY in any of their writings. The bloody anti-Hindu firangi memsahib UPA II Government of India would go out of its way to talk about the porn-artistic freedom of Minority Muslim marauder M.F. Hussein treating the hurt and anguished religious feelings of the Hindus of India as expendable and disposable saffronized communal garbage! The time has come for the Hindus of India to come together as one man to teach a lesson to the firangi memsahib Sonia Congress Party and the UPA II Government in New Delhi.
The Hindus of India have taken note of the fact that a totally innocent and highly respected Sadhvi Pragya lies incarcerated in a prison in Maharashtra for more than 3 years without any charge sheet being filed against her and with no hope of getting released in the foreseeable future, despite the much-touted “free and independent judiciary”! firangi memsahibs of India must know that the wheel of political fortune can get upturned at any moment in a democracy and the same law and legal process that are being manipulated against Sadhvi Pragya by the Sonia Congress Government in Maharashtra can be turned against them at any moment by any successor government with equal viciousness, vindictiveness and political élan and venom, if not more.
Recent history tells us that till April 23, 1945, Adolf Hitler thought that he was the master of the whole of Europe! And yet within a week, on April 30, 1945, Adolf Hitler committed suicide. 64 years later an evangelical marauder catapulted to the position of Andhra Pradesh Chief Minister paid the supreme price for waging a State sponsored evangelical war against Lord Venkateshwara of Tirupati. Let the anti-Hindu evangelical firangi memsahibs know that they are not exempt from the Law of Divine Retribution!!
Recent history tells us that till April 23, 1945, Adolf Hitler thought that he was the master of the whole of Europe! And yet within a week, on April 30, 1945, Adolf Hitler committed suicide. 64 years later an evangelical marauder catapulted to the position of Andhra Pradesh Chief Minister paid the supreme price for waging a State sponsored evangelical war against Lord Venkateshwara of Tirupati. Let the anti-Hindu evangelical firangi memsahibs know that they are not exempt from the Law of Divine Retribution!!
The silent message that is simmering and circulating among the tormented and tortured Hindus of India is this: “WE HAVE TO WAGE A DEMOCRATIC POLITICAL WAR AGAINST A MONSTROUS TYRANY LET LOOSE BY THESE FIRANGI MEMSAHIBS. IT IS ONLY THE THREAT OF VIOLENCE THAT WORKS. WE THE HINDUS OF INDIA IN MAJORITY MUST BECOME MORE ORGANIZED AND MORE MILITANT LIKE THE MUSLIMS OF INDIA TO DEFEND OUR RELIGIOUS RIGHTS. WE HAVE NOTHING TO LOSE BUT OUR STRANGULATING FIRANGI MEMSAHIB’S SECULAR ANTI-HINDU CHAINS”!!!
1 comment:
Thanks for your opinions on Shivaji: Hindu King in Islamic India. I liked your opinions. I read book reviews on different sites, I find your review very genuine and orignal.
Post a Comment